Baking with Olivia and Caroline

August 2021 Recipe – Frozen Lemon Pie

By Published On: July 29th, 2021

It’s summer. It’s hot. And we feel we need to keep the no bake or minimal bake theme going.

Frozen Lemon Pie is a cinch to whip up. With very few ingredients and just a couple of minutes whisking egg yolks and sugar over the double boiler, you’ll have a refreshing summer dessert in no time!

The filling vs. crust debate

When making a pie, yes, you need to have a delicious filling, but for us, it is equally important to have a delicious crust. Nilla Wafers elevate this pie to an entirely new level. We hadn’t had Nilla Wafers in years and honestly forgot about the vanilla-y little wafer cookie. They sure are a yummy treat on their own, but make for an even yummier crust for a dessert such as this! Next level, even.

Frozen Lemon Pie has been said to taste like an orangecicle only in pie form and made with lemons. This recipe was found in our recipe book in Olivia’s handwriting. It was probably written when she was a teen because the recipe was very vague, and instructions were missing. It was more like notes jotted down on a recipe card.

And so, after making the pie a few times, we think we have it perfected. The first time we made it, we chose not to freeze it, the second time we did freeze it. You can do either. Half of our taste testers preferred it frozen, half liked it refrigerated. We also baked the pie crust the first go around, but that is totally unnecessary. The crust held its shape very well refrigerated and frozen.

This pie is not too sweet, has a bit of tartness to it and is just super-duper refreshing.

Crust ingredients:

1 1/4 cup Nilla Wafers
1/4 cup brown sugar
1 stick of butter melted

Directions for crust:

Crush Nilla Wafers in a food processor or blender until course. Melt butter with 1/4 cup of brown sugar. Mix butter and brown sugar together with Nilla Wafer crumbs. Press firmly into a 9” pie plate and set aside.

Lemon filling:

3 eggs separated
2/3 cup sugar
Juice of one lemon and the zest
1 cup heavy cream

Filling directions:

Whisk the 3 egg yolks together with 2/3 cup of sugar, juice of one lemon and the rind over a double boiler until mixture thickens. Set aside to cool.

Beat egg whites with 2 tbs of sugar until stiff peaks form; set aside.

Beat 1 cup of heavy cream until stiff peaks just begin to form. Fold lemon mixture with egg whites and whipped cream together. Pour into pie plate. Refrigerate or freeze.

If you are freezing the pie, remove a few minutes prior to serving. It will make slicing so much easier! Serve with whipped cream (we added candied lemon rinds to garnish our pie, DM us for the recipe).

Olivia and Caroline are enthusiastic foodies and bakers who are constantly in the kitchen, as well as explorers who create their own adventures in our area – and did we mention they are mother and daughter? Follow Olivia on Instagram to see her many creations at @oliviawvalentine.